‘Meet us midway’ – Phumzile van Damme tells Fb boss to ‘take steps’ towards election misinformation
Phumzile van Damme. (TISO BLACKSTAR GROUP (PTY) LTD, Gallo Images)
- Phumzile van Damme says Facebook is not doing enough to monitor misinformation and disinformation related to the 2021 local elections.
- She says false information has been shown to lead to violence in South Africa.
- People need to make sure that what they consume on social media is correct, she says.
Facebook South Africa needs to “come to the party” and put in place systems to monitor disinformation and misinformation related to the 2021 local elections.
This emerges from the former DA MP Phumzile van Damme, the co-founder of the local government’s anti-disinformation project 2021.
On News24’s election podcast, Ballot Box, hosted by political editor Qaanitah Hunter, Van Damme said misinformation about elections was a concern and that social media companies like Facebook should do more to combat it.
“What we saw in the US, for example, the popular narratives about the theft of election results and the inaccuracies of election results … Something similar can happen in South Africa. That is why political parties can say, ‘oh no, the IEC recorded the election results. That’s not right. “And in a climate where it has already been shown that violence can result from disinformation, it can happen,” she said.
READ | Phumzile van Damme brings charges against political parties that spread disinformation
Van Damme said they are advocating Facebook doing what it did in the US election by flagging potentially incorrect information.
When asked about her message to Facebook founder Mark Zuckerburg, she said:
My message would be that here you have the opportunity to meet us halfway. We don’t want to close Facebook. I think Facebook should keep working, but I think there is an opportunity to show goodwill and for South Africa it is an opportunity to take steps in the little window that is left. To say you know we are going to monitor disinformation in all 11 languages, that’s what we’re going to do, that’s what we’re going to do. And then, after the election, begin the conversation about future disinformation surveillance. And I think to prevent a situation where the government starts thinking about regulation that could violate freedom of expression. I think a conversation has to be held, one of the solutions that seeks, and not a bitter one.
Facebook wavers from revelations by whistleblower Frances Haugen, who accused the tech giant of lying to the public for making significant strides against hatred, violence and misinformation.
“On Facebook, I’ve seen time and again that there was a conflict of interest between what was good for the public and what was good for Facebook.”
READ | AWB-marked hate group on secret Facebook blacklist
Van Damme said the company should at least “pretend to care about the impact of misinformation on the upcoming November 1 polls”.
“With the revelations Frances (Haugen) made, at least you’d expect them to pretend to worry. They don’t even pretend to care. And the simple truth is, given the Pressure they have, “In the US you are facing in the EU You are facing many antitrust lawsuits in the US and have received heavy fines running into billions from the EU in connection with the data protection of WhatsApp.
“They focus their business on the so-called global south. And it is important that African countries in particular increase the pressure on Facebook. It is important for us to make this kind of advocacy, it is important for us to exert pressure. And the The fact that they don’t even bother shows how much they don’t care, “she said.
The Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC) has taken a tough stance on misinformation about elections on social media.
READ | Van Damme and Steenhuisen argue about their resignation as MPs
Van Damme said she felt it was important not only to monitor disinformation, but also to protect against incitement to violence.
“When Helen Zille started to make comments about the arrest of the ConCourt and the cooperation of the ANC with the IEC and the ConCourt, it was important to me as a private person to say no, that shouldn’t be said. Where is the evidence of that?
“Or Herman Mashaba’s comments on foreigners. An environment where there are examples of violence against foreigners, where we have just come out of a situation where there was violence. It’s important to say no, do that of remarks not. “
The former MP said she is encouraging South Africans to stand firm against misinformation and “better demand”.